The Underneath

The Underneath


$8.99 View All Available Formats & Editions
Choose Expedited Shipping at checkout for guaranteed delivery by Wednesday, November 20


There is nothing lonelier than a cat who has been loved, at least for a while, and then abandoned on the side of the road.

A calico cat, about to have kittens, hears the lonely howl of a chained-up hound deep in the backwaters of the bayou. She dares to find him in the forest, and the hound dares to befriend this cat, this feline, this creature he is supposed to hate. They are an unlikely pair, about to become an unlikely family. Ranger urges the cat to hide underneath the porch, to raise her kittens there because Gar-Face, the man living inside the house, will surely use them as alligator bait should he find them. But they are safe in the long as they stay in the Underneath.

Kittens, however, are notoriously curious creatures. And one kitten's one moment of curiosity sets off a chain of events that is astonishing, remarkable, and enormous in its meaning. For everyone who loves Sounder, Shiloh, and The Yearling, for everyone who loves the haunting beauty of writers such as Marjorie Kinnan Rawlings, Flannery O'Connor, and Carson McCullers, Kathi Appelt spins a harrowing yet keenly sweet tale about the power of love — and its opposite, hate — the fragility of happiness and the importance of making good on your promises.

Product Details

ISBN-13: 9781416950592
Publisher: Atheneum Books for Young Readers
Publication date: 01/05/2010
Edition description: Reprint
Pages: 336
Sales rank: 99,967
Product dimensions: 6.12(w) x 8.00(h) x 0.90(d)
Lexile: 830L (what's this?)
Age Range: 10 - 14 Years

About the Author

Kathi Appelt is the author of the Newbery Honoree, National Book Award finalist, PEN USA Literary Award–winning, and bestselling The Underneath as well as the National Book Award finalist The True Blue Scouts of Sugar Man Swamp, Maybe a Fox (with Alison McGhee), Keeper, and many picture books including Counting Crows and Max Attacks. She has two grown children and lives in College Station, Texas, with her husband. Visit her at

David Small is the Caldecott Award–winning illustrator of So You Want to Be President? by Judith St. George. He also received Caldecott Honors for The Gardener by Sarah Stewart and One Cool Friend by Toni Buzzeo. He’s illustrated dozens of other award-winning books, including That Book Woman by Heather Henson and The Underneath by Kathi Appelt, and lives in Michigan with his wife, Sarah Stewart.

Read an Excerpt


THERE IS NOTHING lonelier than a cat who has been loved, at least for a while, and then abandoned on the side of the road. A small calico cat. Her family, the one she lived with, has left her in this old and forgotten forest, this forest where the rain is soaking into her soft fur.

How long has she been walking? Hours? Days? She wasn't even sure how she got here, so far from the town where she grew up. Something about a car, something about a long drive. And now here she is. Here in this old forest where the rain slipped between the branches and settled into her fur. The pine needles were soft beneath her feet; she heard the water splash onto the puddles all around, noticed the evening roll in, the sky grow darker.

She walked and walked, farther and farther from the red dirt road. She should have been afraid. She should have been concerned about the lightning, slicing the drops of rain in two and electrifying the air. She should have been worried in the falling dark. But mostly she was lonely.

She walked some more on the soft pine needles until at last she found an old nest, maybe a squirrel's, maybe a skunk's, maybe a porcupine's; it's hard to tell when a nest has gone unused for a long time, and this one surely had. She was grateful to find it, an old nest, empty, a little dry, not very, but somewhat out of the rain, away from the slashes of lightning, here at the base of a gnarled tupelo tree, somewhere in the heart of the piney woods. Here, she curled up in a tight ball and waited, purred to her unborn babies. And the trees, the tall and kindly trees, watched over her while she slept, slept the whole night through.Copyright © 2008 by Kathi Appelt


AHH,THE TREES. On the other side of the forest, there is an old loblolly pine. Once, it was the tallest tree in the forest, a hundred feet up it reached, right up to the clouds, right beneath the stars. Such a tree. Now broken in half, it stands beside the creek called the Little Sorrowful.

Trees are the keepers of stories. If you could understand the languages of oak and elm and tallow, they might tell you about another storm, an earlier one, twenty-five years ago to be exact, a storm that barreled across the sky, filling up the streams and bayous, how it dipped and charged, rushed through the boughs. Its black clouds were enormous, thick and heavy with the water it had scooped up from the Gulf of Mexico due south of here, swirling its way north, where it sucked up more moisture from the Sabine River to the east, the river that divides Texas and Louisiana.

This tree, a thousand years old, huge and wide, straight and true,would say how it lifted its branches and welcomed the heavy rain, how it shivered as the cool water ran down its trunk and washed the dust from its long needles. How it sighed in that coolness.

But then, in that dwindling of rain, that calming of wind, that solid darkness, a rogue bolt of lightning zipped from the clouds and struck. Bark flew in splinters, the trunk sizzled from the top of the crown to the deepest roots; the bolt pierced the very center of the tree.

A tree as old as this has a large and sturdy heart, but it is no match for a billion volts of electricity.The giant tree trembled for a full minute, a shower of sparks and wood fell to the wet forest floor. Then it stood completely still. A smaller tree might have jumped, might have spun and spun and spun until it crashed onto the earth. Not this pine, this loblolly pine, rooted so deep into the clay beside the creek; it simply stood beneath the blue-black sky while steam boiled from the gash sixty feet up, an open wound.This pine did not fall to the...

Reading Group Guide

1. The action in the book takes place in the marshy swampland and deep forests of Texas's bayou region. Research bayous and their ecosystems and prepare a report. In what parts of the world do bayous exist? What kinds of plants and animals live in bayous? How are bayous similar to and different from other ecological environments — for example, what do bayous have in common with the Florida Everglades, and how do the two areas differ?
2. Long before the Europeans settled along the Gulf Coast, a varied group of Native Americans live in the piney woods of East Texas and Louisiana. They were collectively known as the Caddo. It was from the Caddo language that the name for the state of Texas came about. The name meant "friend." In fact, the Caddo were known as a friendly people. Even though Hawk Man and his family weren't Caddo themselves, they might have been welcome in a Caddo village, just as the later Europeans were welcomed. Research the Caddo. There are hardly any left in their original homeland, and they have mostly settled in Oklahoma and Mexico. Why did they leave? What were some of the things that they were famous for? How did they learn to survive in the marshy swamps of their native territory?
1. Grandmother Moccasin and her daughter Night Song are lamia, half-serpent and half-human. Hawk Man is also an "animal of enchantment" [page 61], having been a bird before turning into a man. If you could be a shape-shifter, which animal would you choose to become? What do you think of the shape-shifter rule: "Once a creature of enchantment returns to its animal form, it cannot go back" [page 47]? If you were Hawk Man or his daughter, would you have become an animal again, even if it meant you could never return to your human form?
2. Until he meets Mama the calico cat, Ranger the bloodhound doesn't realize how lonely he is; Ranger muses that when Mama found him, he "didn't know that he needed to not be so solitary until at last he wasn't," [page 30]. What are the differences between being alone, and being lonely? Is it possible to be lonely even when you're surrounded by people?
3. Abused as a child and later abandoned by his father, Gar Face the trapper lives in a world of anger, and his drinking only deepens his hatred. Does anything make Gar Face happy? If so, what is it? Even though he does evil things throughout the book, do you think he deserved to die in the jaws of the Alligator King?
4. When an author assigns human characteristics to non-human beings, this is called anthropomorphism. What are some examples of anthropomorphism in the book? In real life, do you think plants or animals have feelings like human beings do?
5. Sabine the kitten is named for the Sabine River that feeds the Bayou Tartine. Her brother's name is the same as the playful character in Shakespeare's play, A Midsummer Night's Dream — Puck is a mischievous spirit who often gets into trouble. What do the names of some the characters in The Underneath — like those of the kittens, Gar Face, Ranger, Night Song — reveal about their personalities? Does your name have a special origin, or are you named for a family member? How does your name reflect who you are?
6. Ranger, Mama, Sabine, and Puck refer to themselves as a family. What makes a family? Does a family only consist of parents, children, and relatives? Describe your own family — does it include people who aren't related to you?
7. When Puck gets lost in the forest after his mother drowns, he has to learn to hunt in order to eat. Sabine realizes she needs to go out from "the underneath" so she can find food for herself and Ranger, a job that Mama performed. These are just two ways that the kittens have to grow up — what are other examples?
8. Hawk Man, having turned back into a bird in order to find his daughter, spies Puck lost and hungry in the woods, and drops a mouse from the sky for Puck to eat. Name some other acts of kindness from the story.
9. As Gar Face captures Sabine in the yard, Ranger goes wild with fury and lunges at Gar Face, knocks him down, and bites him on the leg — allowing Sabine to escape. Were you surprised at Ranger's reaction? Why didn't Gar Face expect that Ranger might behave this way?
10. "You have to go back for your sister. If something happens to me, promise you'll find her," [page 77]. Did you think that Puck would be able to keep this promise to his mother? Talk about some other promises made by characters in the novel; were they kept? How, and at what cost?
11. Music plays a big role in the book, from the blues songs that Ranger bays into the moonlight to the enchanting lullabies of Night Song. Discuss music and what it means in the story. How does music help some of the characters?
12. Talk about Grandmother Moccasin. Do you think she was selfish for not telling Night Song about the rule that shape-shifters can't go back to their human form once they become an animal? Did she deserve to be imprisoned in the jar for so long? What is the lesson she learns after she's finally freed?
13. One of the novel's main themes is loss. Which of the characters have lost something, and what did they lose? Do the characters who suffer loss eventually find something new to take the place of what is gone?
14. When children don't obey to their parents in The Underneath, bad things happen. Who were the characters who didn't listen to their parents? What were the consequences of their disobedience? Did these characters learn from their mistakes?
15. Dogs and cats are supposed to hate each other, yet Ranger and Mama become close friends. Discuss their unlikely friendship — what were some of the things they have in common? What are other unusual friendships portrayed in the book? Do you have a friend who, on the surface, seems like someone you wouldn't ordinarily like? Why do you get along with this person?
1. The voices of birds, animals, and reptiles tell most of the story in The Underneath. Write your own story from a creature's point of view, whether it's a household pet, or animal in the wild, or bird, reptile, fish, or some other living thing.
2. How does the narrative structure of The Underneath — where several characters take turns telling the story — resemble that of a television show? Research how to write a television screenplay. Choose one scene from the book and write a screenplay based on it, and include the characters' dialogue, the stage direction, and descriptions of the scenery.
3. Ranger the bloodhound bays mournfully about loneliness; drawn to his songs, Mama the calico cat sets out to find who sings them. Pick an emotion — loneliness, anger, fear, love — and write song lyrics, or a poem, about feelings you have.
4. The book's last chapter contains a passage about the trees of the bayou, how they could tell us what happened to Ranger, Sabine, and Puck after the story ends. Write a new last chapter for The Underneath, detailing what the three animals have done since they were reunited.
5. In the book, the hummingbird is described as an "intermediary" and "messenger," a being that is able to travel between life and death because it can fly so quickly. Research the mythology of some of the wild creatures in The Underneath — such as snakes, alligators, or hawks — and create a report about one. Illustrate your report with pictures or illustrations.
An abandoned calico cat, about to have kittens, hears the lonely howl of a chained-up hound dog deep in the backwaters of the bayou, and sets out to find him. When they finally meet, Mama the calico cat and Ranger the bloodhound form a fast and unlikely bond, forged in loneliness and fueled by fierce love. They become a family after the kittens are born, and Ranger urges Mama to remain under the porch and raise Sabine and Puck, because Gar Face — the evil man living inside the house — will surely use her or her kittens as alligator bait should he find them. They'll be safe in the long as they stay there.
But in a moment of curiosity, one of the kittens sets off an astonishing chain of events that reverberates through the bayou, and brings the past together with the present in remarkable ways. Following the tradition of Marjorie Kinnan Rawlings, Flannery O'Connor, and Carson McCullers, in The Underneath Kathi Appelt spins a harrowing yet keenly sweet tale filled with many absorbing themes, such as the power of love (and of hate), the fragility of happiness, and the importance of making good on your promises. This guide is designed to assist your classroom's discussion of this poignant novel.
Kathi Appelt has written a number of successful picture books. This is her debut novel. She lives in Texas. David Small was awarded a Caldecott Medal for So You Want to Be President? He has illustrated many other books for children, including Once upon a Banana and When Dinosaurs Came with Everything. He lives in Mendon, Michigan.

Customer Reviews

Most Helpful Customer Reviews

See All Customer Reviews

The Underneath 4.3 out of 5 based on 0 ratings. 115 reviews.
alittlehobbitgirl More than 1 year ago
My mom talked me into buying this book, I was haveing a depresing day so she took me and my sister to the bookstore. I wasn't really planning on getting it, but mom liked the whole animal theme, so I got it. She started reading it to us, and it was good at first, just what mom had expected, but then it got to Gar-face and stuff and we stoped reading it. But I loved it, and kept reading it, and let me tell you, you have to remember every aspect of this book to get it. All of the storys kind-of weave together to make one thrilling marvelous story. This book is about an abandoned calico cat, who finds a lonely hound dog who is owned by Gar-Face, an evil abused man. The cat is expecting kittens, and when the two bay cats are born they are told to never leave the underneath (under the porch), or Gar-Face would use them as croc bait. But when Puck, the boy kitten, gets a little curious, an adventure takes place, with betrayed snakes, large crocodiles, and shap-shifting birds. With surprises around every corner, this book is sure to keep your intrest. Warning: this book may be scary for younger children, so probably not a good read-out-loud choice.
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
I absolutely love, love, LOVE this book! I began building my home library for my young (5 and 8-year-old) children. I always read the books first to make sure there are no sensitive topics that I would rather avoid at their young age. Although alcoholism is mentioned, it is related to the very mean and abusive character 'Gar Face", which led to a great discussion on avoiding alcohol. I thoroughly enjoyed the story myself! Now my 8-year-old is reading it. He is really enjoying the book also. It's great for building his vocabulary and understanding mataphor. There is wonderful moral to the story, but I'll let you find it out for yourself! Such a wonderful book, destined to be a favorite of yours too!
TeensReadToo More than 1 year ago
I've stated before that if a book can make me laugh hysterically or cry hysterically, it's guaranteed a good review because it means the author has gone above and beyond. That is the case with THE UNDERNEATH. Except, a good review isn't enough for this book. It is not. I only hope that my review can begin to do justice to this amazing work.

THE UNDERNEATH is lyrical, strong, and extremely well-written. It is thought provoking and "can't put it down" fantastic. Kathy Appelt does not lower the bar in the slightest from page one until the book is done. Not one bit.

Appelt weaves a brilliant tale about an old, beaten-down hound dog and the felines he loves. She also weaves an almost entirely separate folktale of a miserable, bitter, shape-shifting snake. How do these two stories fit into the same book? Ask Kathi Appelt, because I'm still trying to figure out how she beautifully intertwined them. But she did. She did.

In the acknowledgements, Appelt mentions advice from M.T. Anderson (THE ASTONISHING LIFE OF OCTAVIAN NOTHING) that she took to heart: "Write what you think you can't." Obviously, this author put her heart and her soul into the writing of a beautiful book, and it has paid off with a tale that will last for generations.

You know that gut feeling you get when you read a book like CHARLOTTE'S WEB or THE MIRACULOUS JOURNEY OF EDWARD TULANE? That Lasting feeling? Lasting wraps itself around you and urges you to read this book carefully because you'll want it in good condition on your shelf for a long time to come. That is this book. This perfect and Lasting book.
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
Great book. The book was a bundle of ropes, in the end the whole book tied together in an unforgettable way.
no-nonsense More than 1 year ago
I guess I will have to go back to prereading books for my children in grades 3-6, even if the book has a Newberry Honor book award, after reading this not-for-the-young book. In the first 13 pages of The Underneath: a heartless family abandons a pregnant cat in the forest, a boy poisons his mother's birdfeeder and you get to hear about the dead birds and her sorrow (while the boy's delight in their suffering is explained as images of blood drip from her hands), a father is a drunkard with the alcohol named, a boy is abused with facial wounds so bad he is permanently disfigured, drunk father passes out, mother abandons family, boy runs away from home . . . does this really sound like a book you want to expose to your young children? It gets worse: revenge leading to suicide, deep anguish at the loss of a loved one, animal torture (dog shot on purpose and not cared for, dog malnourished, dog permanently left on small chain outdoors for years on end as chain becomes embedded in neck, dog kicked in sides, dog hit purposefully in the face with a board (you get to read in detail about the blood in the dogs nose and how it chokes and spits blood and its eyes are swollen shut), cats used as live bait for alligators, cats swung around by the neck, mother cat and kitten are thrown into a bag and then tossed alive into a swamp to drown (you get to read about how the human delights in the suffering of these innocents), and more. I am angry that I was duped by the review and the back cover. My daughter was rightfully upset reading this. I read it after her and was kicking myself that I didn't preread it. Thanks anyway, Newberry Awards, I will use my parental judgement on when to bring up "teachable moments" on alcohol and alcoholism, child abuse, animal abuse, suicide, murder, and runaways. This book might be for teens, but it is certainly NOT for elementary school children.
emmakay11 More than 1 year ago
This book was great and very interesting but the thing I did not like was how short the chapters were. Once you started a chapter it was over. I liked the kittens and the change in Grandmother Moccasin's heart at the end. I also like the poetic language and the way the book flows. I would recommend this book for a child or young adult.
Badger2571 More than 1 year ago
I have read this book twice to my sons. Once at age 7 and 9; recently at ages 9 and 11. The Underneath created a lot of dialog about so many subjects. The characters were fascinating. How Grandmother Moccasin evolved, how Puck matured, and how Gar Face became what he was were deep discussions for my sons. They also enjoyed figuring out the mysteries of the book. There are many mysteries to solve and the author does a great job explaining most of them in the end. It did make a great read aloud; it kept my son's interested and complaining when we had to put the story on hold to go to bed.
college-student More than 1 year ago
On its surface, this is the story of the family that is formed out of the friendship between an abused hound and an abandoned cat. But its multi-layered subtexts explore loss, pain, and the possibility for redemption. One of its messages might be that "hurt people hurt people"-and that ultimately, the only way to end this cycle is to let go of your right to hate by choosing to love. I can't praise this book highly enough. The story is poignantly beautiful, but its language is pure music. Appelt's writing style seems closer to poetry than prose, with lines like these: "Whenever there is a breeze in the old forest, you might, for a moment, realize that the trees are singing. There, on the wind, are the voices of sugarberry and juniper and maple, all telling you about this hound, this true-blue hound, tied to a post. They have been watching him all these years, listening to his song, and if he know what the trees were singing, it might be about how he found a friend" (25). Its themes are deep enough that its intended audience is ageless. My highest recommendation might be in that I've already bought it for a fourth grader, a children's lit professor, a high schooler, and my cousin in college. =)
violin2 More than 1 year ago
The author has woven a compelling story with her poetic use of words. It was beautiful to read but heart-wrenching at times. The evil was hard to stomach and I shed tears for the animal characters but the climax and resolution was satisfying. It absorbed me as I turned pages to discover the ending and then I didn't want it to end. This story haunts me still. It is a book to treasure but don't leave it on a shelf afterwards. Pass it on to a friend who loves animals, the natural world--someone who can endure the agony of good vs. evil.
Anonymous More than 1 year ago
Please read this book. It is just about the best book ever. It is so moving, and truly beautiful how everything comes together in the end. It's written in a kind of poetic way, and I love it. I wish that everyone in the world could read this book. I absolutely recommend it and rate it an 11 or more out of 10. Amazing. Truly Amazing.
ScoutLB More than 1 year ago
The author draws you in....tells you what you need to know...explains the enchantment of the surroundings with great understanding and knowledge...gently explains how the 'man' (Gar Face) - becomes evil, or would that be, uncaring? She tells the story of how the two almost mythical/mystical beings came to be...and then sits you right up front, unfolding the story of a hound, a mother cat, and her twin kittens. Charming, suspenseful, worrisom, fascinating...a book that I would read aloud to jr. hi students...The author has more than voice; she has song; she has soul.
MaseratiPi More than 1 year ago
I felt such a range of emotions while reading this incredible story. The way Appelt conveys wretched loneliness and the desperate hunger for companionship is haunting yet identifiable.
Guest More than 1 year ago
This was simply a wonderful and unique book to read. There were so many interesting characters. The book was written in such a way that I couldn't put it down until I found out what happened to each character in the end. I can't wait for others to read it and love it as much as I did!
Redhope on LibraryThing More than 1 year ago
The cover of this book does not describe adequately the content within! I was surprised at how dreadfully sad parts of this book were and the mystical side of the story was a big surprise. I am not familiar with Native American mythology, but it soon became obvious that something ancient, powerful and unearthly was being woven into the lives of the abandoned animals and the main human character. I was entranced by its harsh reality, beauty and tenderness, and like many reviewers below wonder if this book really does appeal to middle grade readers.
KindiC on LibraryThing More than 1 year ago
A very different type of either love it or hate it.
kikione on LibraryThing More than 1 year ago
This is story of how love and loyalty can arise amidst abuse and hatred. This book really blew me away. At times I was filled with intense and passionate hatred and then the next was reduced to tears by the simple love that can be shown between two living creatures. I love how the book is broken up into short chapters that are readable and leave you hanging on for the next. I had a hard time putting this book down. It doesn't pull any punches. You feel and experience the pain and horror of abuse and the devastating, overwhelming feelings of loss. At the same time you learn about love and loyalty and the power of a common bond.What a great book! A wonderful author!
melopher on LibraryThing More than 1 year ago
I read this aloud to my 11yo son and 9yo daughter, and although we found it to be a much different book than we had anticipated (the wonderful illustrations portrayed a much more innocent story) we were all on the edge of our seats until the end. I would read an hour a day, and the kids still didn't want me to stop. So for those wondering if the appeal is limited to adults, I can tell you that it just wasn't the case in our house. Perhaps reading it aloud made the difference, I will say that it was a lot of fun on my part--the writing is just so lyrical.The funny thing is I typically steer clear of books with heavy spirituality/mysticism/mythology for young ones, as well as books that involve such nasty characters/events as Gar Face. I've stopped reading books before and put them away for such content. The Underneath, however, felt different to me. It didn't feel without reason, it didn't feel unreal, it didn't feel without least overall. It was an experience, I will say that.My criticisms, that I noticed because I read it aloud to my children, would be first that the repetitive poetic language did get a little cumbersome in some parts. There were some lines that were repeated so often that it just got plain tiresome. "Here. Right here." "So black it was almost blue." "go back a thousand years..." Second, the story--being split between the story of the hound & cats and the story of the snake for much of the book--was too heavily weighted on the snake/mystical side for too much of the book. Especially in the beginning. We all kept wanting to hear more about the animals on the cover of the book instead of the repetitive prose about Grandmother Moccasin and the trees. It did tie together nice at the end, but it would have been nice to have it more balanced.We did enjoy looking up all the different animals and trees mentioned in the book (easy when reading w/ an iphone beside you!) and it is a story that will stick with us. My 9yo daughter has strong hopes that she'll be able to see the movie version soon. She is convinced they must be making it already--that goes to show, I think, how vivid a story The Underneath told.
BugsyBoog on LibraryThing More than 1 year ago
This mythical fantasy book weaves together two good stories. One story involves Grandmother Moccasin who has been entrapped in a jar in the roots of an archaic tree. She has been nursing her rage against the world because her daughter and only companion left behind her snake form to make a life as a human. When Grandmother Moccasin becomes a tree, she plays a pivotal role in the climax of the other story, one set in modern day times. In this tale, an old abused hound dog, named Ranger, befriends a mother cat and her two kittens, Puck and Sabine. Ranger¿s owner, Garface, is the combination of everything evil and disgusting in the world. Garface kills the mother cat, which leads to Puck being separated from his family. He frantically tries to find his way back, maturing and growing all the time. Thankfully, the story ends well.I love animal stories, but the sadness in this one overwhelmed me. The happy but violent ending almost wasn¿t worth the long torturous journey to get there. The man in this book was positively revolting, and almost everything he hid disgusted me. I will gladly read another book by this author, as the text was beautifully done. The setting and the descriptions were excellent, but the subject matter of this book was just too dark, too dismal, too sad. I hope that author can turn to a slightly more uplifting story next time.
allisonmclean on LibraryThing More than 1 year ago
This book wasn't what I thought it would be at all. It is a children's book but it was very different than any book I've ever read for this age group. The tone and voice of the narrator reminded me of one that you see often in books for adults and young adults, but I was surprised to see it used here for children. I'm not sure if it works as a children's book.
BNBHarper on LibraryThing More than 1 year ago
Summary: An abandoned calico cat hears a dog howling in the distance. The cat goes to search for the dog and finds the dog, Ranger. Ranger convinces the cat stay in the underneath so, the Dog owner, Gar-Face will not feed the kitty to the alligators. The abandoned Cat ends up having the kittens but the tough part is keeping the kittens in the underneath. Response: I love animal books as you probably can tell by the list of books I chose for this assignment. I am a big fan of the book, "Shiloh", which is still my favorite but this was a good book also. Theme/Connections: Animals; Love; Friendship
brie13028 on LibraryThing More than 1 year ago
Great book, the stories leave off suspensfull and wondering whats going to happen next.
SheilaCornelisse on LibraryThing More than 1 year ago
I found this book a little disjointed. Its a confusing combination of the mythological and reality. The mere existence of a thousand-year-old snake and alligator is unbelievable. The author should have stuck to the main story of the struggles of the hound dog and cats as the try to survive the cruelty of Gar Face. I have my doubts as to whether this book would appeal to children.
pbamy on LibraryThing More than 1 year ago
Although it is a beautifully written story it is a complex story that mixes magic and shifts in settings in time and place and has a poetic stile that may be challenging for the younger of the age group it is recommended for. Having said that it is a very original story with a rich and poetic style. The story of animals in crisis is also a very popular one. I would recommend this story to those who love artistry and would also recommend it as a mentor text when teaching writing style, voice, and organization.
tapestry100 on LibraryThing More than 1 year ago
The Underneath is a powerfully written story about family, whether it is your family that you are born to or the the family that you choose for yourself. It is a story about promises. It is a story about anger and revenge. It is a story about redemption. It is a story filled with too many chapter breaks.Did that last sentence feel a little out of place? That's how I felt about the frequent chapter breaks in the book. The book is 311 pages, with 124 chapters. Some chapters are as little as one paragraph. It seemed very unnecessary in many cases, and became very distracting, breaking up the story too many times.However, the story itself is still very powerful and touching. You know you're reading a good book when the villain does something extraordinarily evil and you just want to hit him yourself. Several times over. The message about keeping your family close, whoever that family ends up being, and about keeping your promises, is told very well, the two messages intermingling throughout the story.Highly recommended.
karen813 on LibraryThing More than 1 year ago
Well written but I question it's appropriateness for children. I was disturbed by much of the content and while I recognize the necessity of it (it is important for the storyline) I don't know if a child would be able to see past the violence to understand the motivation behind it. I can't say that I enjoyed the book but I can appreciate the importance of the book.