In the Company of Others (Mitford Series #11)

In the Company of Others (Mitford Series #11)

by Jan Karon


$14.40 $16.00 Save 10% Current price is $14.4, Original price is $16. You Save 10%. View All Available Formats & Editions
Choose Expedited Shipping at checkout for guaranteed delivery by Tuesday, October 22


Follow Father Tim and Cynthia on their journey to research his Kavanagh ancestry in the Irish countryside in this novel in the beloved Mitford series from #1 New York Times bestselling author Jan Karon.
Vacation—the very word has been foreign to Episcopal priest Tim Kavanagh. Now retired from tending his flock in the village of Mitford, he is making good on a promise to show his wife, Cynthia, the charming land of his Irish ancestors. But after arriving at a Lough Arrow fishing lodge in the midst of a torrential downpour, the charm disappears.

They find their holiday upended by an intruder, a treasured painting is stolen from the lodge, and a family conflict dating back nearly a century turns even more bitter. As three generations struggle to find deliverance from the crucifying power of secrets, Tim and Cynthia stumble upon a faded journal that might just explain the crime—and offer a chance at redemption.

Product Details

ISBN-13: 9780143119913
Publisher: Penguin Publishing Group
Publication date: 08/30/2011
Series: Mitford Series , #11
Pages: 464
Sales rank: 94,962
Product dimensions: 5.00(w) x 7.70(h) x 0.80(d)

About the Author

Jan Karon is the author of the bestselling series of nine Mitford novels featuring Father Timothy Kavanagh, an Episcopal priest, and the fictional village of Mitford. Set in the foothills of the Blue Ridge Mountains, Karon's Mitford books include At Home in Mitford; A Light in the Window; These High, Green Hills; Out to Canaan; A New Song; A Common Life: The Wedding Story; In This Mountain; Shepherd's Abiding; and Light from Heaven. The Father Tim Novels include "Home to Holly Springs" and "In the Company of Others," set in County Sligo, Ireland. There are over 40 million Mitford and Father Tim novels, childrens books, and CDs in print.


Blowing Rock, North Carolina

Date of Birth:


Place of Birth:

Lenoir, North Carolina

Read an Excerpt


The beams of their hired car scarcely penetrated a summer twilight grown dark as pitch in the downpour.

His wife's fear of being hemmed in was only slightly greater than his own. As the road narrowed to a lane the width of a sheep track, he took Cynthia's hand and peered out to sullen hedges pressing on either side. He was peevish at being crammed into a rain-hammered Volvo with a testy driver and a box of books which for some bizarre reason they had thought they couldn't live without.

He closed his eyes, then thought it best to keep them open. He was a lousy traveler. Indeed, the aggravation of getting from Atlanta to Dublin had exceeded his worst expectations.

Following a delay of seven hours due to storms in the Atlanta area, the trip across the Pond had been an unnerving piece of business which shortened his temper and swelled his feet to ridiculous proportions. Then, onto a commuter flight to Sligo Airport at Strandhill, where—and this was the final straw, or so he hoped—they met the antiquated vehicle that would take them to the lodge on Lough Arrow. When he located an online Sligo car service a month back and figured how to dial the country code, hadn't he plainly said this trip would celebrate his wife's birthday as well as her first time in Ireland? Hadn't he specified a nice car?

In any case, they'd be getting no consolation from the driver, a small, wiry fellow so hunkered over the wheel that little more was visible than his headgear—a mashed and hapless affair of uncertain purpose, possibly a hat.

He had visited County Sligo as a bachelor ten years ago, with his attorney cousin, Walter, and Walter's wife, Katherine; they had driven to and from the fishing lodge on this same road. In any weather, it was no place to meet oncoming vehicles.

He unbuckled the seat belt and leaned forward.

'Aengus, I think we should pull off.'

'What's that?'

'I think we should pull off,' he shouted above the din of rain and wipers.

'No place to pull off.'

'Ask him how he can possibly see anything,' said Cynthia.

'How can you possibly…?'

'I see th' wall on m' left an' keep to it.'

'Doesn't appear to be any cars coming, why don't we stop and wait it out?' Torrential. Second only to the hurricane he'd driven through in Whitecap.

'I'll get round th' bend there an' see what's ahead.' Aengus muttered, shook his head. 'Bleedin' rain, an' fog t' bleedin' boot.'

'It's what keeps you green,' shouted his wife, opting for the upbeat.

'That's what they all say. M'self, I'm after goin' on holiday to Ibiza.'

He sat back and tried to stuff his right foot into the shoe he'd removed on entering the car.

'Timothy,' said his wife, 'if there's no place to pull off, what happens when people meet another vehicle?'

'Someone has to back up. I never quite understood how that gets decided. Anyway, there'll be a pull-off along here somewhere; they seem to appear at very providential places.'

'When he said he keeps to the wall, I realized those aren't hedges. There's stone under all those vines.'

He thought she looked mildly accusing, as if he'd neglected to pass along this wisdom.

'Walls!' reiterated Aengus. 'Landlord walls.'

He had promised her this trip for years, and for one reason or another, it had been often deferred, twice rescheduled, and even now there was a glitch. Last week, Walter and Katherine had been forced to postpone tomorrow's planned arrival in Sligo until four days hence. Walter's apologies were profuse; after months of red tape and head scratching, he said, the date for meeting with a big client had come out of the blue. His cousin hated the inconvenience it would cause; after all, Katherine was the only one among them with guts to drive the Irish roadways. She was a regular Stirling Moss—fearless, focused, fast. Too fast, the cousins had long agreed, but what could they do? They were both cowards, unfit for the job.

Until Walter and Katherine arrived at the lodge with wheels, he and Cynthia would be stuck like moss on a log. 'How will you manage?' Walter had asked.

'Very well, indeed,' he said. In truth, Walter and Katherine's delay was the best of news. He and Cynthia were badly in need of four uneventful days, having been thrashed by the affairs of recent months.

Soon after she fractured her ankle and lapsed, unwilling, into what she called her Long and Unlovely Confinement, he learned he had a half-brother in Mississippi. There had been a few shocks in his seventy years, most of them occurring during forty-plus years as a priest, but never anything like this.

As a kid, he'd once pulled that nearly impossible stunt of St. Paul's and prayed without ceasing—for a brother. It didn't work. Then, sixty years later, there was Henry Winchester. Henry, with acute myelogenous leukemia, needing stem cells from a close relative.

He had quartered in Memphis with Cynthia for weeks, giving over his stem cells through apheresis, standing watch at Henry's bedside and feeling in an odd and confusing way that he was fighting for his own life. His long road trip in a vintage Mustang hadn't helped, of course. Then, playing out the proverb of 'when it rains it pours,' came the sudden flare-up of his diabetes only days ago.

'There's no way we're not going,' he told his wife, whose recent sixty-fourth birthday had gone largely uncelebrated.

'There's no way we're not going,' he told his doctor, who had seen him through two diabetic comas and was as hidebound as they come. Hoppy Harper had preached him the lipids sermon followed by the exercise sermon, pulled a stern face to ram the points home, then caved. 'So, go,' he said, popping a jelly bean.

Four days. To walk the shores of Lough Arrow. To row to an island in the middle of the lake and picnic with Cynthia. To sit and stare—gaping, if need be—at nothing or everything.

It would be roughly in the spirit of their honeymoon by the lake in Maine, where their grandest amenity was a kerosene lamp. It had rained then, too. He remembered the sound of it on the tin roof of the camp, and the first sight of her in the white nightgown, her hair damp from the shower, and her eyes lit by an inner fire that was at once deeply familiar and strangely new. He hadn't really known until then why he'd never before loved profoundly.

Cynthia nudged him with her elbow. 'We're around the bend.'

He leaned forward and shouted, 'We're around the bend. You were going to stop.'

'There's nothin' so bad it couldn't be worse—another bend comin' up.'

He sank back in the seat. 'That's the way of bends. They keep coming up.'

'What am I t' call you?' shouted Aengus. 'Are ye th' father or th' rev'rend?'

'Reverend,' he said. 'I'm the Father back home, but in your country only Catholic priests are addressed as Father.'

'Here for th' fishin', you an' th' missus?'

'No fishing.'

' 't is th' fishin' capital of th' west, you should have a go at it.'

'We could reach out and touch those walls,' she said. 'It looks like we're going to rip the side mirrors off their hinges.'

He made another feckless go at shoeing his right foot. 'Always looks that way.' His earlier foray here had earned him rights to play the old head. 'Never happens.'

Aengus gave him a shout. 'I've been thinkin', Rev'rend.'

'What's that?'

'There's seven or eight them Kav'na families in Easkey.'

'Good. Wonderful.'

She foraged in her handbag, which did double duty as mobile library and snack hamper. 'Here,' she said. 'Eat this. It's been four hours.'

Raisins. He ate a handful with a kind of simple shame, recalling chocolate with macadamias.

She leaned close, her breath warm in his ear. 'Do you think he does this for a living? He isn't wearing a uniform or anything.'

'Ask him,' he said. He was sick of yelling.

She unbuckled her seat belt and leaned forward to the hat. 'Mr. Malone, do you do this for a living?'

'What's that?'

'Drive tourists. Is it what you do… all the time?'

' 't is the only time. 't is m' brother's oul' clunker. I mow verges for th' Council at Sligo.'

She sat back and rebuckled. 'He mows verges,' she said, looking straight ahead. 'It's the only time he's done this.'

There was no point in pursuing that line of thought. 'The sides of the road where weeds grow,' he said, in case she didn't know from verges.

Rain drummed the roof. The fan in the dash spewed air smelling of aftershave. They moved at a crawl.

'Mother of God!' shouted Aengus.

The sudden slam of brakes jolted them forward. A blinding light… on top of them. His heart pounded into his throat.

Aengus flashed the Volvo's high beams, scraped the gears in reverse, and squinted into the rearview mirror.

'Bloody lorry,' he snapped. 'We'll be backin' up.'


The walls ended; the rain slackened; parting clouds liberated scraps of pale light. The hedges now were merely tumbled stones and August bloom twined with ivy, foxglove, scarlet creeper.

Aengus Malone had learned a certain dexterity on his mower; his skill at locating and backing into the previously overlooked pull-off had been brilliant. The lorry driver had given three blasts of his horn as a thumbs-up.

'That was some scrape you bailed us out of,' he said to Aengus. 'Well done.'

'It's m' lucky hat that done it.' Aengus reached up and patted the thing. 'Me oul' mum give it to me.'

'If it weren't so dark,' said Cynthia, 'we might see a rainbow.'

'There's some as see rainbows at night, but those would be fairies.'

'You believe in fairies?'

'Ah, no, not a bit. But they're there noneth'less.'

'You've never seen one, then?'

'If it's fairies ye're after, they're said to be very numerous in Mayo.'

On a slope in a grove of ancient beeches, the dusky, formless shape of the lodge appeared, its windows luminous against a starless night.

His wife drew in her breath.


'That would be candles burnin',' said Aengus. The Volvo rattled over a cattle grate. 'Looks like th' rain's shut down your power.'

'Stop,' said Cynthia. 'Please.'

Aengus braked; the motor idled.

'It's the most beautiful sight I've ever seen.'

She sat for a moment, bound in one of her spells, then opened the door. A pure and solemn air spilled in; his right foot slipped into his loafer.

She got out of the car and stood looking along the slope to the fishing lodge, at fog drifting among the cloistered beeches. 'Listen,' she said.

They listened.

'Nothin' much t' hear,' said Aengus.

Rain dripped from the shadowed trees, pattered on the roof of the car; a breeze stirred.

He watched as she got back in the car and closed the door and looked at him and smiled. Then she leaned to him and kissed him. Her faint scent of wisteria mingled with the Sligo air. He had never been so happy in his life.

As they drew up to the lodge, figures appeared on the stoop, silhouetted against the light from the open front door. Three barking dogs bounded onto the gravel and squared off with the Volvo.

There was a considerable shaking of hands with innkeepers Liam and Anna Conor, as the dogs ganged a-glee about their feet—two Labradors, and a Jack Russell dancing on its hind legs.

Anna, the striking-looking woman he'd known a decade earlier, gave him a hand-wringing that jimmied his teeth. He admired all over again her tousle of copper-colored hair and, without meaning to, blurted the sentiment aloud.

They were joined by a white-haired old man wearing a tie and cardigan and brandishing a walking stick. In the gabble of greetings, he decried their weather as 'foul and infernal.'

Somewhere, thanks be to God, something was cooking. 'Lamb,' he said to his wife. He could devour a table leg.

He recognized the feeling he experienced on his wedding day nearly eight years ago—as if he'd lost the proper sense of things and stepped outside his body. He was a cannonball fired directly from the quiet desperation of a hired car into a domestic muddle of energy and good cheer.

They were herded through an entrance hall, its walls fairly crammed with fish mounted in glass cases, and into a sitting room lit by candles and an open fire. A half-finished jigsaw puzzle was spread on a table among a loose aggregation of sofas and wing chairs.

He felt at once the keen pleasure of the room: its book-lined walls and good pictures, the impression of ease.

In a corner, three men murmured over a card game by the light of a candle. A distinguished-looking fellow sat reading a newspaper by the firelight and stroking his white mustache; upon seeing them, he stood at once and buttoned his jacket.

'Heads up, gentlemen…' Anna lifted a small bell from the sofa table and pealed it. 'Reverend Timothy Kav'na and Mrs. Kav'na of North Carolina, meet our anglers—Tom Snyder of Toronto, Hugh Finnegan of Maryland, and there's Pete O'Malley. Pete's a Dub who lived many years in Texas.'

'O'Malley here.' O'Malley stood, saluted. 'Welcome.' The other two pushed back their chairs, stood, raised a hand.

'They're with us every August since 1997,' said Anna. 'They're after catching our dinner tomorrow.'

He gave the trio a thumbs-up. 'Go, Terps,' he said to Hugh Finnegan.

'And there's Seamus Doyle from up the hill at Catharmore, who visits most evenings with the Labs. Seamus is our master of assorted entertainments, chiefly checkers and jigsaw puzzles.'

Seamus of the white mustache crossed to them for another round of hand-shaking. 'How long will you be in Ireland, Reverend?'

'A couple of weeks.'

'They say a couple of weeks makes a habit.'

'We wouldn't be against it. Not a bit.'

'I spent a lot of years in the States. Always good to see someone from the oul' country, as I call it.'

He surveyed the room and those in it—a whole universe of life and pluck at the end of a narrow road in the middle of nowhere.

Somehow, the two three-suiters, the umbrella, and the glasses case he'd left on the backseat got toted in by Liam. Then came Aengus, tailed by the two Labs, schlepping the carton of books, their carry-ons, a flashlight, and the box of raisins. Off they went across a sitting room carpet worn to the lining, and along a hall, where the lot of them vanished into the gloom. A young woman with a nose ring and cheek tattoo offered hot towels; the Jack Russell sat at his feet, looking up, a chewed shoe clenched in its jaws.

It was all a dazzle. After years of talking, planning, and idle speculation, they were here. He wanted to sprawl before the open fire like a lizard and lose consciousness.

Cynthia had stepped away to look at a painting he remembered—of men in curraghs spearing basking whales in the treacherous seas off Arranmore.

'It's good to have you back,' said Anna. There was an honest country style about her garb of shirt, skirt, apron, and clogs.

'It's great to be back. The trip is my wife's birthday present.'

' 't is no surprise your wife is beautiful.'

'Yes,' he said. 'Inside and out.' He wasn't likely to get over his pride in showing her off. That they were married at all still waked an astonishment in him. 'We're both needing a few days to unwind. There's no better place to do it than here.' The most excitement he could recall from his first visit was a wandering cow in the kitchen garden.

He wiped his hands with the towel and replaced it on the tray. 'Many thanks,' he said to the server, who cast a cool glance beyond his.

'We're so sorry about the power being out, but it happens often with the big rains.' Anna turned and spoke to Cynthia. 'I hope you don't greatly mind candle power, Mrs. Kav'na.'

Cynthia came to them and slid her arm in his. 'Not in the least. I love candle power.'

'Such dreadful weather, it's been raining for three weeks. I do apologize.'

'Please call me Cynthia, and you needn't apologize for anything at all. I love rain.'

The old man stumped up with his cane. 'A villainous rain!' he declared in a loud voice.

'Meet my father, William Donavan, he's our keeper of the fire at Broughadoon. The Kav'nas are from the States, Da. North Carolina.'

'Rev'rend, missus, good evenin' to you. We're destroyed by th' rain entirely.' William removed a handkerchief from his vest pocket and gave his nose a fierce blowing.

He reckoned William a handsome man, even with a once-broken nose that had been badly set. The rope of an old scar crossed his left temple.

'Now, now, Da, not entirely. But no one goes hungry,' she assured them, 'our Aga is fired by oil and there's a lovely rack of lamb roasting for your dinner.'

'I'm desperate with th' hunger,' said the old man.

'Our own lamb,' she said. 'We hope you'll approve. The dining room in thirty minutes, then, straight down the hall and to the right. Flashlights and chamber sticks on the book table.'

'Chamber stick,' said Cynthia, not knowing the term.

Anna laughed. 'Something to stick a candle in and light the way to your bedchamber. Oh, and when you're ready to retire, we'll bring buckets of hot water so you can have a wash.'

A good-looking woman brimful of energy, just as he remembered. Ten years ago, she appeared to run the place virtually single-handed. He didn't remember meeting William before, or Liam.

'And what may I get you in the meanwhile?' asked Anna. 'Whiskey? Glass of wine? Cup of tea?'

'A cup of tea,' said his wife. 'I'll just find the powder room first.'

'Ditto,' he said.

'Straight across there, next to the sheep painting. And behind the sofa there's the honesty bar and a box for outgoing mail.'

Aengus arrived at his elbow. Something looked very different about their driver, though he couldn't say what. A brown fellow, wrinkled as a dried apple.

'Bang-up, Aengus. Thank you.'

'Ah, well, we didn' get drownded, so.'

Owing to the criminal diminution of the dollar, this would be no mean gratuity; he dug into his pocket and pressed more than a few euros into Aengus's hand. He was in turn handed a business card troubled by age and a series of phone numbers crossed through in pencil.

'You'll have no vehicle a'tall 'til th' cousins come. Best give us a shout if there's need.'

'What if you're mowing?'

'We'll send a cousin of our own, we've thirty-odd, m' brother an' me.'

'Thank you, Mr. Malone,' said Cynthia. 'Be safe out there. Not too much backin' up, if you please.'

Aengus grinned, a sudden and remarkable sight, and hurried out.

'You first.' She nudged him toward the sheep painting.

'Ladies first.'

'What's that smell?'

'Turf. They're burning turf. Takes some getting used to.' He remembered how much he'd learned to like the pungent odor.

Liam bounded up. 'Everything is in your room, Reverend. I hope you'll be happy with us. Welcome again to Broughadoon.'

'Thank you, we're thrilled to be here.'

A lean, handsome Irish face, he thought, with intense blue eyes and hair graying at the temples. 'I don't believe we met when I visited a few years ago.'

'I was helping rebuild the west wing of the oul' place, and keepin' my head down. There's still work going on, I hope it won't disturb you. Anyway, you'll see more of me this trip, I'll be givin' a hand with dinner and cookin' your breakfast!'

'The full Irish breakfast I so fondly remember?'

'And skip the blood pudding, Anna says.'

'Correct. My wife, however, is eager for the blood pudding!'

Liam laughed. 'Is she Irish?'

'Her maternal double-great-grandmother was from Connemara, but we know nothing about her except she was very cheerful-looking and played the fife.'

'I expect you met the lorry coming in.'

'I'll say.'

'Sorry about that. It was my wine wholesaler, he was held up by the storm and finally had to run for it. By the way, the delay of your cousin and his wife opened up the room they requested. Always the silver lining.'

'Always,' he agreed. 'The books. I don't recall seeing so many books last time, or paintings.'

'My father's library passed to me years ago; we finally got the shelves built last spring.'

'Beautiful millwork on the shelves.'


'You did it?'

'My da was a builder, I grew up with a hammer an' saw. I wanted his books to have a good show. A few good pictures also passed to me, including a Barret you'll see in the dining room—it's a beauty in afternoon light. Anyway, books and pictures for me, and the house up the hill for my older brother, Paddy, thanks to God.'

'Thanks to God!' Sitting nearby with Seamus, William thumped his cane on the floor.

'Refresh my memory. What's the meaning of the name Broughadoon?'

'From the Irish, both an dún—hut of the fort.'

'This being the hut, and the fort being…?'

'Catharmore—on th' hill above.'

'So. It's a pleasure to see an open fire.'

'Ireland's gone modern, I'm afraid, though Anna and I try to keep some of the oul' ways. Speakin' of oul' ways, sorry about the power, 't is usually back on in no time.'

Through the open window, he glimpsed the taillights of the Volvo disappearing along the road. And there, on the antlers of a mounted deer head, hung Aengus's hat, as shapeless off as it had been on.

'Aengus Malone forgot his hat,' he told Liam. He felt oddly remorseful.

'So he did. We'll leave it just there 'til he comes again.'

They had no plans for Aengus to come again, as they'd be traveling with Stirling Moss in the future. 'A pity he left it,' he said, 'his old mum gave it to him.'

'Aengus Malone forgot his hat,' William announced to Seamus. 'Leave it just there 'til he comes again.'

Seamus was filling his pipe. 'Aye,' he said, looking up and smiling. 'Will do.'

On going in to dinner, he spied a large, well-thumbed book lying open on a table by the dining room door. Names lined the pages.

'Want to sign the guest book?' he asked Cynthia.

'I'll do it tomorrow; I'm famished.'

He couldn't resist. Squinting in the dusky light of the candle sconces, he picked up the pen and made the inscription.

Timothy A. Kavanagh, Mitford, North Carolina.

There. His Irish name in an Irish book, on the heels of an Irish rainstorm. It was official.


Excerpted from "In the Company of Others"
by .
Copyright © 2011 Jan Karon.
Excerpted by permission of Penguin Publishing Group.
All rights reserved. No part of this excerpt may be reproduced or reprinted without permission in writing from the publisher.
Excerpts are provided by Dial-A-Book Inc. solely for the personal use of visitors to this web site.

Reading Group Guide


Launched with a three-month stay on the New York Times hardcover bestseller list, In the Company of Others follows Father Tim Kavanagh—now retired from tending his flock—as he makes good on a promise to show his wife, Cynthia, the land of his Irish ancestors. In a charming fishing lodge in County Sligo, any hope for a peaceful sojourn is dashed by an intruder, a stolen painting, and a bitter family conflict dating back three generations. New and old fans alike will be riveted by this compelling tale of the desperate struggle to hide the truth at any cost and the powerful need to confess.



Jan Karon is the bestselling author of the Mitford series and Home to Holly Springs. She lives in Virginia.



Q. What strikes one immediately when reading this novel is the emphasis on language—particularly the lyrical voices of the Irish characters. Can you talk about how the Irish vernacular has inspired your writing?

Irish vernacular is full of color and surprise, metaphor and double meaning. I grew up on remnants of this speech because our North Carolina mountains are populated with people of Scots-Irish heritage. I had heard it all my life, in a form diluted by time, but still resonant of the original and full of sap.

Q. Tell us about your travels to Ireland and interactions with its people. What were some of your favorite experiences?

I love the country house hotels, where either Irish or English family descendents are trying to make a new living off old ground. No chain lodgings, no commercially driven meals, no expanses of asphalt and industry, but (usually) innkeeper descendents of the original owners, gorgeous views, family pride, food from their own gardens or sheepfolds or local farms, and, if one has Irish blood, they may end up treating you like family.

Q. You clearly did a lot of research into medical practices in nineteenth-century Ireland. How did you go about it? What were the more surprising things you learned?

I learned what a scamp Dr. Wilde was (I enjoy gossip laced with history), how rare was the man with the gall to pull teeth for the populace (one usually had to do it oneself), how innocent they were about germs, for Pete's sake, and I can't think what else. I loved living in that time period through my writing and research. I never intended to go on about Fintan O'Donnell's life there, but he kept at that journal and so did I. My favorite character next to the good doctor himself was, of course, the Lad. He was my Dooley of decades past.

Q. Dr. O'Donnell's journal is a fascinating part of the novel—it's a treasure trove of history and a portrait of life in a bygone era. Why did you decide to incorporate it into the book?

I needed a place to hide what had to be hidden, and the theft needed to be more complex than a random robbery—if only to keep the author interested. The journal simply spread out over years and other lives as dandelion seed dispersed on the wind.

Q. W. B. Yeats figures prominently in the book. Aside from those mentioned in the novel, which of his works would you recommend to your readers?

Might as well get the complete works and go at a run with it. It makes one giddy, like spinning around and around, then stopping and falling over.

Q. Early in the novel, you have a refreshingly candid admission of the emotional toll the priesthood takes on Tim as he realizes that his heart is exhausted by a life of giving to others (p. 96). Yet he continues to minister to the Conor family. As you have explored Father Tim's character throughout the novels, how have you come to understand this trait of his?

He can't help himself. He is attracted to suffering and grief and loss and there's no way around it. God wired him this way and he has learned to just go with it—doesn't resist it, just gets into whatever is calling him out and gets to the heart of it if it can be done. He is a kind of warrior who, when he hears the battle cry, is on his horse and into the fray and devil take the hindmost. As Cynthia says to him, 'I do books, you do people.'

Q. When we travel, as Father Tim and Cynthia do here, we learn about the places and people we visit, but we also learn about ourselves. How has this trip changed the not-very-adventuresome Father Tim?

I'm not sure it has changed him. When the next book opens, we find he is very happy to be rooted once again in Mitford 'like a turnip.' No, he will not be seeking any more adventures. Any adventure will have to come to him—which, of course, it most certainly will.


  • Ireland is itself a character in the novel, noted throughout the book for the beauty of its landscape, and for the intensity of emotion in its history and people. Liam captures this perfectly when he quotes the poet Henry Wadsworth Longfellow: 'By suffering worn and weary, but beautiful as some fair angel yet' (p. 37). Which characters best embody this quotation? Think of the multiple ways in which beauty can manifest itself.
  • Karon has filled the novel with excerpts of poetry and prose; these quotations are included not only for their beauty but for the way they capture the meaning of the scenes that contain them. Locate the quotation that you found most affecting; explain why it moved you, and why it was integral to the passage in which it appears.
  • Swans are powerful metaphors in the novel. What do they represent for Tim? At what points in the narrative are they mentioned? What do you think is the significance of the scene on p. 373 when Tim sees a flock of swans flying overhead?
  • Have you been to Ireland? If so, does the author's depiction of the landscape and the people match your experience? Why or why not? If you've not been to Ireland, how does this story affect the likelihood that you'd visit?
  • The novel is not written in the first person, but we very much follow the novel from Tim's perspective, knowing his interpretations and private responses to the book's events. How does this form of storytelling create the sense that Tim is confiding in the reader? What does the reader know of Tim's feelings that the other characters do not?
  • Tim asks his Irish friends to call him Tim rather than Reverend, but they resist. Why is this? What authority does his title convey? Does maintaining this formality make it easier for the characters to confide in him?
  • Tim considers Ireland's lush green landscape as 'composed of more, he reckoned, than a plenitude of moisture—something supernatural was ever rising from the core of this ancient land carved by glaciers' (p. 68). What is the supernal force he is referring to?
  • Dr. O'Donnell's journal captivates Cynthia and Father Tim. What are particular aspects of the story that speak to them? What are some similarities between the lives of the people who lived in 1860s Ireland and those we encounter in parts of the book set today? What are differences?
  • What are the advantages to having readers experience Dr. O'Donnell's journal in the doctor's own words rather than it being related by one of the modern-day characters?
  • Customer Reviews

    Most Helpful Customer Reviews

    See All Customer Reviews

    In the Company of Others 3.4 out of 5 based on 0 ratings. 286 reviews.
    ErieChild More than 1 year ago
    This is my first B&N review and I just couldn't let the negative reviews get posted without my input. Jan Karon is a pure delight. I loved the Mitford series but I think the Father Tim series are a real treasure. I think the Home to Holly Springs was her best book but I so enjoyed this novel set in Ireland. Father Tim's advice to Anna about dealing with problem children was so true and simple I underlined it to read again and be able to share with friends. A cast of many when you factor in the journal sub story and a fresh setting but in the company of old friends - Tim and Cynthia. I loved the dialect and thought she captured it very well. A mark of a great writer; I want so badly to go to Broughadoon. Could not put it down and can't wait for the next book. A wonderful writer and a warm and admirable lady.
    Anonymous More than 1 year ago
    How this can be Jan Karon's favorite book is surprising. I have thoroughly enjoyed all of the Mitford books and the first of the Father Tim series; however this book misses the mark. It is slow moving and the Irish brogue makes it a struggle to read at times. I am about half way through the book as I write, and I have serious doubts whether I will make it to the end. In the next book I hope Karon brings Father Tim and Cynthia back home where we can enjoy their adventures with the characters we have come to know and appreciate.
    Anonymous More than 1 year ago
    I don't think my words can do this book justice. All I can say is take the time to read it. I'd also like to suggest another book, "When God Stopped Keeping Score," an intimate look at the power of forgiveness and yet, it's about so much more. I loved every minute of it. Given the chance, it too will change your life.
    Bookmobile_Driver More than 1 year ago
    I have to tell you up front Jan Karon is my favorite author. I've read all her books and loved all but one. That said, I'll try to give as honest a review as possible. In the Company of Others is the second book in the Father Tim series, the first being Home to Holly Springs. These two books vary from Karon's nine books in the Mitford Books series only in location and supporting characters. Father Tim is the main character in both series, but the Father Tim books are set outside of Mitford. This book takes place in the town of Sligo, Ireland where Father Tim takes his wife Cynthia to show her where he had visited ten years earlier with his cousin Walter and Walter's wife Katherine, before Tim and Cynthia were married. Throughout the book, there are references and communication with family and friends back home and Mitford fans will feel comfortable with that. What struck me throughout was how easily Father Tim slipped into the hearts of the Sligo people. Just as he did in Mitford, he spotted problems and found ways to solve them. Cynthia's foot is injured and she is unable to get around easily, leaving Father Tim to help the family members of the bed and breakfast where they are staying as well as others. Of course, Cynthia assists in handing out love and care from the bed and breakfast. The author uses a book-within-a-book approach here that I found quite effective. Father Tim and Cynthia find a handwritten journal written by a doctor who had lived in 1860's and read them since Cynthia is limited in what she could do. What amazed me was the research that must have gone into writing the 1860's story to make it historical correct. This book will hold your interest from beginning to end, and when it does end, you'll want to know when the next book in the series will be ready. I highly recommend it.
    pippy More than 1 year ago
    I started reading this book from the library and realized early it was going to be one of those treasured stories I would read again so I bought my own hardcover copy, something I rarely do! I have been to Ireland so I enjoyed and identified with the atmosphere and the proclaimed beauty of the land as Jan Karon wrote so well and lovingly about. The descriptions of the inn and innkeepers were entirely realistic and salty, down to some domestic problems that Father Tim was expertly able to resolve after years of unresolved heartache in the family they boarded with. Since Tim and Cynthia were marooned at the inn anyway, this was a great way to flesh out a story and add some depth to characters who would normally be marginal in a travelog. There were also other inn guests that added both comic and striking portraits of passing travelers. I also liked the flashes back in time as Tim and Cynthia read an 1860's journal that led them to solve a mysterious theft from the inn while they were there. The weaving of history, culture and atmosphere with some inspirational thoughts was a masterpiece by an author who has surpassed all her previous books with this newest work.
    Anonymous More than 1 year ago
    She really triumphed with this one!! I have never felt when reading a novel like I'm really part of their family except with Ms. Karon's Books AND I feel I'm right there...on the the the home... wherever they are at the moment...I'm Wowed Every Time!! Only Wish she would write Faster!! Your Fan from South Carolina!
    DenisePW More than 1 year ago
    Won't pay this price. Sorry publishers. Another author off my list.
    jovilla on LibraryThing More than 1 year ago
    Like a visit with old friends! Father Tim and his wife Cynthia visit Ireland expecting the usual vacation but instead find themselves involved in family dramas: one taking place in the family owned inn with it's cast of memorable characters and another in an old journal detailing the lives of the family living in that house more than a century before. The author has a way of making her characters come to life becoming almost like much loved family members that the reader is delighted to see again.Nd
    porch_reader on LibraryThing More than 1 year ago
    Jan Karon's books are the ultimate in comfort reads for me. This second book in the Father Tim series (which follows the seven books in the Mitford series) finds Father Tim and his wife Cynthia on a trip to Ireland. During their stay at a country lodge, we meet the extended family who runs the lodge and watch as Father Tim helps them sort through problems from the distant past and the present day. Although I missed spending time with the familiar characters from Father Tim's hometown of Mitford, Karon does a nice job introducing us to a new cast of characters. [In the Company of Others] isn't quite as good as the best of the Mitford series, but it was just right for a busy December read.
    MrsLee on LibraryThing More than 1 year ago
    Father Tim and Cynthia finally arrive in Ireland. They have a harrowing trip, but arrive safely at a charming fishing lodge full of friendly people. Or so it seems. Before long their plans are turned upside down by injury, theft and heartbreak. Timothy and Cynthia being who they are, they jump right in and start loving everyone, warts, bumps, frowns and all.At times, the outcome of these books seems pat to me. Problems of people don't get resolved so well, if ever, in real life. However, having lived through the changes that forgiveness and forgiving bring about in ones life, and having seen the miracles in the lives of others, I can't say it doesn't happen. Perhaps not as neatly and fluently as in fiction, but it does happen. Love changes you. People heal. It's never too late. Miracles do happen. We need to be reminded of these things now and then. That is why I love reading these stories.
    tjsjohanna on LibraryThing More than 1 year ago
    While I was expecting to get another story that delved into Father Tim's history, this was the story of the people Tim & Cynthia stayed with on their trip in Ireland. I enjoyed the flavor of the country that came through in the dialect and descriptions. I also really liked the picture of Tim & Cynthia's marriage - the ways they give and take and enjoy each other. One the overarching themes of the book was forgiveness and love - and the need to let God work in our hearts. Lovely story.
    tututhefirst on LibraryThing More than 1 year ago
    I am a fan of Jan Karon's Mitford series, out of which this book and its prequel Home to Holly Hills sprang. The gentle, fun, caring people of the town of Mitford captivated me. And Fr Tim Kavanaugh with his goofy dog, his shy and tentative walk through life were always comfortable, interesting, and well-developed stories.Home to Holly Hills, the first in this new "Fr Tim" series was a stretch, taking the main character out of the comfortable setting of Mitford and taking him through a gut-wrenching return to his home town to discover his long-forgotten, or kept secret past. It was barely believable, but all of us who loved Fr. Tim put up with it. Now comes this latest one, and it is enough to make a reader cry. It's a poorly disguised excuse for a religious tract to offer conversion to Jesus as salvation. Those of us who loved the Mitford series knew all about Fr. Tim's religious beliefs and didn't need the proselytizing that really pops up in this one.It is not as well written as the previous ones, with a story inside a story that spreads confusion about what is going on, and why it's being introduced. In addition, her attempts to make a mystery story out of this family drama are annoying. There are characters that are stereotypical Irish drunks, the obligatory loopy dog, the dying old lady itching to be saved, and people with enough secrets stored up to sink the proverbial ship. I just couldn't warm up to this group, and can't decide whether I want her to continue this series or not. A true disappointment.
    khiemstra631 on LibraryThing More than 1 year ago
    In this installment of the Father Tim series, Tim and Cynthia Kavanaugh finally make their long-awaited trip to Ireland. It's the first time they've really gone anywhere just for fun since their honeymoon. Unfortunately, their departure is delayed, and once the do arrive, Cynthia re-injures her weak ankle and is basically confined to quarters for the duration of their stay. They stay at a family-run inn located next door to the local manor house, occupied by the estranged, drunken mother of one of the inn's owners. A journal from the 1860's details the construction of the manor and the life of its owner and serves to occupy Cynthia during her convalescence. Lengthy excerpts from the journal bog the book down in places, but it does eventually become an interesting story in its own right. The entire book picks up speed as it goes along when a robbery occurs and other interesting events also add flavor. A worthwhile read.
    JaneAustenNut on LibraryThing More than 1 year ago
    Jan Karon has done it again, another great Father Tim Novel. This one takes place in Ireland and is a very good novel. I just love everything Jan Karon writes.......she has such a great christian perspective to all her books! Well done Jan!
    LynndaEll on LibraryThing More than 1 year ago
    Jan Karon's warm and gentle voice imbues "In the Company of Others" with the same ambience we've come to expect from the other Father Tim/Mitford novels. Father Tim and his charming wife, Cynthia, finally travel to Ireland. As usual, plans go awry - more than once.Father Tim's ability to cope with an endless number of hurting people who seek his help land him and Cynthia in the middle of a very dysfunctional family where secrets pop up like leprechans. Interwoven with Irish poetry and a doctor's journal from the 1800s, the plot never misses a step.Jan Keron does have one writing technique that became an irritant in this book. Her penchant for leaving gaps in major scenes only to hear the information later in conversation tripped me up once or twice. The literary device left me scrambling to catch my balance in the story. But for that, I would have rated the book as a five.
    cee2 on LibraryThing More than 1 year ago
    In the most recent book in the MItford series, Father Timothy and Cynthia Kavanaugh finally take their trip to Ireland. Of course, it's not the vacation they expected, but their faith sees them through many trials, both their own and their new friends. As always, these characters inspire me.
    foggidawn on LibraryThing More than 1 year ago
    I loved Jan Karon's Mitford series, particularly the earliest volumes in the series. In the Company of Others is the second volume in a continuation series, the Father Tim novels. I didn't much care for its predecessor, Home to Holly Springs, but put up with it in hopes of the series improving. It did, slightly, though not enough to bring this book up to the same level as the best of the Mitford series. I think the issue is that, while I enjoy reading about Father Tim, it is the supporting cast that really makes the series work. While Fr. Tim is at least accompanied by his wife Cynthia in this book, they are uprooted and surrounded by a new cast of characters at an inn in the Irish countryside. While some of the new characters are engaging, there's just not enough substance there to make up for the lack of the Mitford regulars. Moreover, Karon introduced a story within the story in the form of an old diary, a tactic which met with only limited success. I was left wondering, was there not enough plot for a full book without that added device?I enjoyed this read, and would recommend it to fans of Karon's earlier work, even those who were disappointed with her previous Father Tim book. If you're not familiar with Karon, start with At Home in Mitford, not one of these more recent novels, as they do not show her at her charming best.
    Anonymous More than 1 year ago
    I had the hardest time, getting through this book, twice. Not sure why.
    Anonymous More than 1 year ago
    This story starts out ok but there are too many characters to keep straight. Fr. Tim and his wife, Cynthia, are still delightful. Including the entries from the journal they find on vacation in Ireland, does add to the development of the story, but the entries are too long. I had trouble caring for the problems of all of the characters. There is happiest in the end.
    Anonymous More than 1 year ago
    Anonymous More than 1 year ago
    Anonymous More than 1 year ago
    Ilovemister More than 1 year ago
    I have now read all of her books and have kept them all. I absolutely loved all of her books. She is defininetly one of my top three authors. I have to agree with some of the reviewers. The story within the story got tiresoome. This was the least favorite of all of her books. 
    Anonymous More than 1 year ago
    Anonymous More than 1 year ago