It is Barnacle Barb's 108th birthday, but she is miserable. To cheer her up, the pirate crew gets a game of Hammer the Hammerhead going. Things are looking up, until Barb's glass eye pops out! Barb thinks her eye is lost forever, until it shows up as the finishing touch in Pegleg's birthday necklace. Finally, Barb can enjoy her day, in a very pirate-like way!